(This is really addressed mostly to the Reformed Christians out there. The rest of you are welcome to come along for the ride. Be sure to check out the Youtube clip!)
Too often, we approach theological debate like BattleBots:
IN THIS CORNER, WITH A COMBINED EVANGELICAL POPULARITY IN EXCESS OF A LOT, ARMED WITH SIMPLE APPEALS TO THAT “OLD FASHIONED GOSPEL”, BELIEVERS’ BAPTISM!
[wild cheering and hooting]
AND IN THIS CORNER, WITH AN AGE OF LEAST 500 YEARS, WEIGHED DOWN WITH SCRIPTURE VERSES AND LOGIC, WITH A STRIPPED-DOWN COMPASSION CHASSIS, INFANT BAPTISM!
[the audience erupts in golf claps]
FIGHT!!!!!!
And then the two systems go at it, ripping chunks off each other, spraying bits of tradition and logic everywhere.
Admit it. You know that this is true. In fact, you’ve done this before. “Ooh, now he’s going to bring up the bit about free will, and then I’ll clobber him with Romans 9! FLAWLESS VICTORY!”
I used to be like this. (Truth be told, I’m probably still like this from time to time.) But, over time, God has shown me how very wrong this attitude is. First, you have lost sight of the fact that you are talking to another human being; indeed, a brother in Christ. Second, you have lost sight of the purpose of theology.
In his first letter to the Corinthians, Paul writes:
Now concerning food offered to idols: we know that “all of us possess knowledge.” This “knowledge” puffs up, but love builds up. If anyone imagines that he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know. But if anyone loves God, he is known by God. (1 Corinthians 8:1-3)
Paul is about to deal with a theological controversy. Indeed, he is about to take sides in the debate. But, before dealing with the theological issue, he addresses the underlying heart issues. Knowledge makes you proud. You start thinking that you know what’s up. You begin to believe that your wisdom and superior intellect have brought you to the place of understanding. Paul disagrees. Knowledge is not the most important thing.
Love is the most important thing.
I’m not that old, but I’ve been around long enough to see people hurt through poor theology. Bad beliefs lead to bad living, and they suffer. So, I want to teach a young woman that when the Bible says that God is our Father, it doesn’t mean that God has a hair-trigger temper that is ready to go off at any minute. You know, kinda like her father. This sort of theology is about love.
This can extend to debates about things like baptism. Yes, I believe the Bible teaches that the children of believers are to be full participants in the sacraments of the Church, including baptism and communion. I also believe that it’s possible that poor belief in these areas leads to poor living, resulting in suffering for my brethren.
But that’s now how these things are usually done. Instead, we haul out the BattleBot called “paedobaptism”, load it up with high-octane Calvinism, strap on the Westminster Confession, and wade in.
So, how are you conducting yourself with your theology? Is good doctrine a way that you minister to your brothers, as you yourself are ministered to? Or are you too busy tinkering with your theological BattleBot to care?